Why do Exercise Needs Vary Between Individuals? Explained

The endless parade of social media fitness influencers making intense workouts look effortless leaves many of us questioning our abilities when we fail to mirror such results. We pour endless energy into following their prescribed fitness formulas only to stall out on progress after a few weeks.

So where does the disconnect arise? The problem lies in the one-size-fits-all approach promulgated through glossy mainstream programs promising ripped abs or marathon finishes to anyone willing to put in the work. In reality, no such universal hidden key unlocks every individual’s fitness potential equally. 

So, as we read on, we will discover why do exercise needs vary between individuals. So, without further ado, Let’s get started!

Biological Building Blocks: Nature’s Athletic Assembly Instructions

women of different races sitting on a couch

Why do exercise needs vary between individuals? At its core, the vast differences in our fitness potential and exercise needs are traced back to genetic legacies passed down by ancestors over generations. Like specialized craftsmen, our genes knit together the foundational biological building blocks making us uniquely equipped for certain sports or training responses.

These inherited athletic assembly instructions provide the scaffolding upon which we construct fitness achievements through years of careful training. Let’s break down key genetic gifts and physical traits that shape your body’s exercise capabilities and needs:

1. Muscle Fiber Typology: Born for Endurance or Power?

The vast variability in strength, speed, and endurance traces in part to differences hardwired into individual muscle fibers dictating their contractile properties:

Slow Twitch Muscle Fibers – Endurance All-Stars

These oxidative fibers utilize oxygen efficiently to resist fatigue enabling extensive exertion required for endurance sports like distance running or cycling. If you won the genetic lottery by packing more slow-twitch muscles, you likely excel at lower-intensity activities demanding hours of sustained effort before hitting exhaustion. Consider a career as an ultra-marathoner.

Fast Twitch Muscle Fibers – The Power Athletes

Alternatively, these fibers fatigue faster but produce short explosive bursts ideal for power sports like weight-lifting or sprinting. Abundant fast twitch muscles prime your body for seriously heavy deadlifts, lightning 100m dashes, or acing the broad jump in your combined testing.

While everyone possesses a patchwork quilt of both muscle types, fiber type ratios differ substantially based on genetic directives ultimately predicting innate predispositions towards feats of speed and strength or untiring endurance capacity. Exploit what you inherited.

2. Metabolic Efficiency: Not All Calories Created Equal

Further personalized athletic variation arises from differences in how efficiently our cells extract energy from food or expend calories through activity. Nutrient processing and usage rates vary wildly between people.

Ever wonder why your friend indulges nightly in pizza and beer yet stays rail thin? Meanwhile even smelling a cupcake condemns you to three extra pounds? Partly thank metabolisms.

The precise caloric consumption and burn rates traced to underlying metabolic processes and mitochondrial densities predispose some bodies to effortlessly shed fat while others relentlessly hoard every molecule. Our molecular factories simply create not all calories equal.

What may prove a dangerously high-calorie diet for some merely maintains an ideal physique and fuels intense training for those winning the metabolic lottery.

3. Body Composition: Impacts of Carrying More Muscle or Fat

Body composition represents the balance between lean muscle mass versus fat tissue accrued on your frame. And it significantly dictates caloric requirements and ideal training modes.

Pound for pound metabolically active muscle burns through more energy than fat even at rest. So the greater muscle you carry from diligent strength training, the higher your resting caloric burn and intake needed to avoid wasting away.

Think Dr. Rock eating endless raw eggs to fuel his heavyweight lifting regime in between workouts.

Conversely, those beginning fitness journeys while carrying excess body fat stores often better tolerate lengthy, low-intensity steady state cardio over highly intense training intervals which prove overwhelming initially.

So, whether you spend hours gently jogging or religiously lifting heavy depends partly on your ratio of muscle to fat determined through caliper body composition testing.

Health Conditions Change the Game

atheletes putting their hands together for a huddle

Health conditions can alter the answer of why do exercise needs vary between individuals. Prior injuries, heart conditions, and arthritis represent just a few complications demanding activity modifications to prevent further harm.

For example, running long distances proves extremely risky for those with prior stress fractures or unstable knee joints. Heavy Olympic lifts may exacerbate hypertension. In both cases scaled back lower impact activities like swimming and yoga better support health improvements and injury prevention.

By accounting for personal combinations of muscle fibers, metabolic traits, body fat percentages, and any health issues, you establish the first critical plank in engineering structured fitness plans aligned to your distinctive biological build.

Of course, non-biological lifestyle variables also shift exercise requirements dramatically between any two individuals.

Lifestyle Demands: Impacts of Environment and Occupation

Even two clones matched on every conceivable genetic and physical metric would struggle to achieve identical fitness outcomes if immersed daily in radically divergent settings or professional demands. Our surroundings and routines hold immense influence in shaping ideal exercise dose prescriptions.

Consider a few lifestyle variables that alter training needs:

1. Occupational Activity Levels

Take work regimens. The average postal worker relentlessly pounding the pavement on delivery routes logs over 10,000 steps and 20-plus flights of stairs daily. Their occupational activity levels alone provide a powerful training stimulus. Attempting exhausting Crossfit workouts after work courts severe injury.

Conversely, the desk-bound Silicon Valley coder risks negative health consequences tied to excessive sedentary time if relying solely on work activity. This group requires dedicated scheduled exercise for maintaining basic function and metabolism, let alone fitness gains.

2. Everyday Movement Patterns

Along with workplace physicality, overall movement patterns in daily living dictate exercise requirements. Tracking steps makes quantifying lifestyle activity easier.

Folks averaging under 5,000 steps daily have far different training needs than those tallying over 15,000 simply through their non-exercise routines and habits.

For instance, car dependence, abundant office hours, and television-oriented leisure time all reduce daily caloric burn (and likely prolong lifespan sitting risks) for some lifestyles. Exercise must offset this effect.

Others lacking cars who walk for transportation, household needs, or recreational hobbies accumulate far more extensive daily exertion summing when combined with dedicated workouts to excessive overtraining if unmatched to actual fitness level.

3. Stress Impacts Energy In vs. Out

Furthermore, studies clearly demonstrate links between psychological stress states and disruptions in training capacity through pathways like elevated cortisol.

Financial worries, work burnout, lack of sleep, family demands, and mental health conditions all drain energy stores needed for optimal exercise performance and recovery according to sports psychiatry research.

Attempting exhausting boot camp or CrossFit-style training under high anxiety frequently worsens conditions and threatens overtraining injury. Restorative yoga or gentle walking aims to replenish depleted reserves before intensifying training under distress.

4. Age-Related Training Shifts

Age also prompts careful exercise calibration as joint integrity declines and injury risks heighten. National guidelines dictate dropping high-intensity, bone-jarring workouts involving multi-directional lunges or excessive plyometric jump training for aging adults.

Though genetically gifted exceptions like world-class master athletes defy norms, most face progressive activity reductions over the decade’s absent strategic mobility work and Cross-training modifications.

Women face additional considerations during pregnancy and postpartum phases also demanding customized training adjustments like Kegel-focused pelvic floor exercises.

Clearly, no singular exercise prescription proves appropriate over every life stage or circumstance. Required fitness modifications link clearly to constraints imposed by our current reality.

Psychology Shapes Outcomes: Motivation, Enjoyment and More

two people of different personalities sitting on two chairs talking

Finally overlying these outward lifestyle influences, lie a tapestry of psychological elements uniquely shaping each person’s relationship with exercise and associated training capacities.

While less tangible than occupation or injury, factors like motivation, enjoyment, self-confidence, and social support contribute immensely to outcomes.

1. Motivation Matters

Individuals cite over 50 different motives for exercising according to surveyed research. Desired outcomes span physical health improvements, sports performance enhancement, weight management, social connections, stress moderation, and simple enjoyment in movement.

Clearly, the specific activities, intensities, and social formats selected by a fiercely competitive amateur triathlete fixated on qualifying for world championships differ dramatically from someone simply seeking respite from anxiety through gentle yoga flows.

Tailoring exercises to individual “whys” ensures efficiency towards desired ends.

2. Confidence is Key

An additional psychological contributor lies in self-efficacy beliefs dictating perceived competence and confidence levels around various pursuits. Those less athletically assured often opt out of team sports or advanced lifting programs to avoid social embarrassment or injury while confident peers eagerly sign up.

3. Enjoyment Enhances Adherence

Likewise, basic preferences dictate activities we find intrinsically pleasurable and thus continue pursuing long-term. So, while pre-dawn runs or crowded gyms prove demotivating for some, others eagerly awake or socially connect through such formats.

Preferences also encompass desired levels of structure ranging from solitude in solo sessions to camaraderie within organized programs.

In total, psychological diversity introduces immense variability in optimal exercise design.

Goal Pitfalls Undermining Progress

a man walking on a rocky path in the dark

While a personalized approach optimizes outcomes, several pervasive mental traps trip up those exercising:

1. The Comparison Game Wins No One

Measuring workouts against peers often discourages through distorted self-perception despite relative gains. Avoid linkage between self-worth and the fitness leaderboard.

2. Progress At Your Pace

Climbing the ladder non-linearly stays the norm. Avoid assumptions about universally applicable linear skill progressions. Be patient but persistent in the process.

3. Redefine Failure

Missed sessions or bad workouts are not irrevocable failures. Reset unhelpful mental models setting conditions for self-fulfilling prophecy of defeat amidst life complexities.

4. The More the Merrier Mentality

Attempts to perpetually increase training frequency, intensity, and volume court harm. Listen to signals warning of overtraining risks. Moderation trains long-term.

Bottom Line

So, after learning why do exercise needs vary between individuals, next time yet another airbrushed fitness model breezes through a workout seemingly impossible to replicate in your reality, remember – your exercise needs differ substantially. And that’s OK. Avoid unfair comparisons. Instead, purposefully engineer training aligned to your unique biology, lifestyle, and psychology employing the steps outlined here. Commitment to the process liberates your best self.

Sign Up Here!

Get notified when more articles like these get published.

Share Article

Sign Up

Get notified when this course becomes available again!